Monday, June 19, 2017

Book Review: 'The Return of Depression Economics and the Crisis of 2008' by Paul Krugman

Review by Susan Gardner
The Return of Depression Economics and the Crisis of 2008 
By Paul Krugman 
$24.95, 224 pages 
W.W. Norton 
New York: December 2008


I'm tempted to say that the crisis is like nothing we've ever seen before. But it might be more accurate to say that it's like everything we've seen before, all at once: a bursting real estate bubble comparable to what happened in Japan at the end of the 1980s; a wave of bank runs comparable to those of the early 1930s (albeit mainly involving the shadow banking system rather than conventional banks); a liquidity trap in the United States, again reminiscent of Japan; and, most recently, a disruption of international capital flows and a wave of currency crises all too reminiscent of what happened to Asia in the late 1990s.
Reading Paul Krugman always makes me feel like a smarter person and a better citizen. As an economist with a common touch, he shares the ability with a couple of other specialized authors -- Stephen Jay Gould and Carl Sagan -- to make clear some very complicated concepts from a specialized subject area, and to make the reader enjoy the experience.
In The Return of Depression Economics and the Crisis of 2008 Krugman undertakes a bit of timely recycling and updating of material, taking dead aim at the current fiscal meltdown. This book is a repurposing of his previous work that focused on the 1990s tanking of the Asian and Malaysian economies, "which," as he writes in the introduction to this edition, "turns out to have been a sort of rehearsal for the global crisis now in progress."
As the block quote that opens this review indicates, there's much more to this new edition than the mere Asian crisis as well. He takes us through the paces of a variety of many previous downturns, both shallow and deep, and explores their similarity (and unlearned lessons) in just the right amount of accessible detail. Throughout the book, he uses the simple concept of a babysitting co-op to illustrate the complex interplays of national and international economies, bringing a down-to-the-earth style to the larger concepts of gluts, recessions and boom times. What happens when members of the babysitting group fear that no babysitting will be available in the future? Why, a credit freeze, of course, with no one daring to go out because they want to save their chits for future better weather. This illustrative device is a gem, one returned to repeatedly during the course of the work.
"What the world needs now," Krugman explains, "is informed action; and to get that kind of action, ideas must be presented in a way that is accessible to concerned people at large, not just those with economics Ph.D's."
The book's early chapters make a clear-cut case for the victory of capitalism over communism in the world as we know it (as opposed to the world in which many theorists still wish to reside). With the downfall of Soviet Russia and its satellites, he argues, we're no longer arguing about whether capitalism or communism will prevail:
For the first time since 1917, then, we live in a world in which property rights and free markets are viewed as fundamental principles, not grudging expedients: where the unpleasant aspects of a market system--inequality, unemployment, injustice--are accepted as facts of life. As in the Victorian era, capitalism is secure not only because of its successes--which, as we will see in a moment, have been very real--but because nobody has a plausible alternative.
This situation will not last forever. Surely there will be other ideologies, other dreams; and they will emerge sooner rather than later if the current economic crisis persists and deepens. But for now capitalism rules the world unchallenged.
This is not to say that Krugman does not see a wider range of tweaking capitalism on a more universal and socialistic model than fanatics of Milton Friedman are willing to endure. Indeed, conservatives undoubtedly would view many of Krugman's proposals (like the much-touted-of-late Swedish model of government takeover of vital industries) as not capitalistic at all, but a very thin free-market veneer painted onto the dreaded all-powerful state. But then, dealing in degrees of nuance has never been the strong point of Chicago-school economics. And I'm sure many would miss Krugman's longer view of history that he salutes in that final paragraph in the blockquote above; an economist with the long view and grasp of social and cultural forces spanning centuries surely has a more sanguine view of the world than the Reaganites.
More than most economists, Krugman takes pains to explain the crucial part that perception and psychology plays in markets. This is important, and worth more than the passing nod that is common (and again, it's where his babysitting co-op model comes in handy). Whether bravado or anxiety is based on reality or not, at the macro level, these emotions can drive risky bubbles or sink even the most stable market, completely untethered to whether the fundamentals are in line with the perceptions.
The funny thing is that once you take the possibility of self-fulfilling crises seriously, market psychology becomes crucial--so crucial that within limits, the expectations, even the prejudices of investors, become economic fundamentals--because believing makes it so....
... because crises can be self-fulfilling, sound economic policy is not sufficient to gain market confidence--one must cater to the perceptions, the prejudices, the whims of the market. Or, rather, one must cater to what one hopes will be the perceptions of the markets.
This acknowledgement of the major part that psychology plays in our economy is part of the foundation for Krugman's renowned and dogged insistence on the value of government regulation. Without the assurance that the playing field is level for insider and outsider--or that the traded instruments are even understood enough to properly regulate--the world is going to face crisis after crisis, with no economic lessons and learned and millions suffering from the whims of mass financial stampedes surrounding unregulated "magic" kind of packages like the CDOs that finally unraveled the world market this past fall.
In the end, Krugman's most lasting insight, the he returns to again and again in The Return of Depression Economics and the Crisis of 2008, is that even when times are wonderful--indeed, especially when times are wonderful--we need to have oversight and accountability built into the economic system through regulation, and we need to stick to it rigorously:
... anything that has to be rescued during a financial crisis, because it plays an essential role in the financial mechanism, should be regulated when there isn't a crisis so that it doesn't take excessive risks.
For this insistence, backed up with case history after case history, this latest from Krugman is worth the cover price alone. The fact that economic theory is finally packaged and explained in a manner accessible to the average interested layperson, however, is what makes the book priceless.


Editor's note: This review was originally published at the Daily Kos, which notes that its "content may be used for any purpose without explicit permission unless otherwise specified." The original page can be found here. Like what you read? Subscribe to the SFRB's free daily email notice so you can be up-to-date on our latest articles. Scroll up this page to the sign-up field on your right. 

No comments:

Post a Comment